Phylloxera & Rootstock Selection (SO4, 110R, 3309C, 101-14, Riparia Gloire)
Most grapevines are grafted onto a rootstock. Here is why, and how SO4, 110R, 3309C, 101-14 and Riparia Gloire differ.
Phylloxera is a small, aphid-like root-feeding insect native to North America. It reached France in the 1860s on imported American vines and, by the late nineteenth century, an estimated two-thirds of Europe's vineyards had been destroyed. American vine species had co-evolved with the pest and some of them, V. rupestris, V. berlandieri and V. riparia, are resistant, while European Vitis vinifera does not, so growers graft vinifera onto American-derived rootstocks. Once phylloxera is established the only way to manage an infestation in the long term is to replant on vines grafted to a resistant rootstock, and most grapevines today are grafted. Around 99% of commercially available rootstocks are made of some combination of three American species, Vitis riparia, V. rupestris and V. berlandieri. Rootstock selection rests on soil pests, the potential vigor of the site, vine spacing and desired vine size, and how a rootstock behaves comes from its interaction with the scion grafted onto it.
Start WineSchool Level 1. Free, in the app, under a minute a lesson.
Open WineSchoolThe Phylloxera Crisis and the Rootstock Solution
Grape phylloxera (Daktulosphaira vitifoliae) is a small, yellowish, aphid-like insect native to North America that feeds on grape roots. Genomic analysis has confirmed that wild Vitis riparia is the source of the phylloxera that invaded Europe, most likely from populations along the upper Mississippi River. The pest reached France in the 1860s on imported American vines. European Vitis vinifera has no defences against it, while the American species V. rupestris, V. berlandieri and V. riparia coevolved with the insect and are resistant. By the late nineteenth century an estimated two-thirds of Europe's vineyards had been destroyed. Using American vines as outright substitutes failed because the quality of the resulting wines was lacking. Laliman, a French viticulturist, was the first to suggest grafting susceptible wine varieties onto rootstock of resistant American species, and Gustave Foëx, director of the École Nationale d'Agriculture de Montpellier, was among the first scientists to test it; his 1882 booklet of clear instructions for small growers fuelled the widespread adoption of American rootstocks in Europe. Grafting gave resistance to phylloxera while keeping the desirable flavours of the vinifera variety.
- On resistant rootstocks, phylloxera cannot feed on the main roots and can only nibble the tips of the feeder roots; because those tips regenerate all the time, vine and insect can coexist
- Resistance is not absolute. UC Davis's Dr. Andrew Walker says, “More and more rootstocks that we thought were totally resistant are supporting rather large populations of phylloxera”
- Phylloxera can crawl, but it travels mainly with people: with vines, in moved soil, on equipment such as leaf trimmers and harvesters, and in irrigation water
- Once phylloxera is established in a vineyard, the only control option is to replant Vitis vinifera grafted to tolerant or resistant rootstocks
- Phylloxera reached France in the 1860s on imported American vines; by the late nineteenth century an estimated two-thirds of Europe's vineyards had been destroyed
- Grafting Vitis vinifera onto American rootstock gives resistance to phylloxera while keeping the desirable flavours of the vinifera variety, and most grapevines today are grafted
- SO4 (Oppenheim #4, Selektion Oppenheim 4) is a V. berlandieri x V. riparia cross from Germany, released in 1941 by the School of Viticulture at Oppenheim and selected from Teleki 4A
- 110R (Richter 110) crosses Rességuier no. 2 berlandieri with Rupestris Martin and was released in 1889; among the berlandieri hybrids authorised in France, SO4 and 110R are used in much of today's vineyards
- 3309C (Couderc 3309, Riparia tomenteuse x Rupestris Martin, 1881) and 101-14 Mgt (V. riparia x V. rupestris, Millardet, 1882) are moderate- to low-vigor rootstocks, as is SO4
- Riparia Gloire de Montpellier is a pure V. riparia selection from France, with Viala listed as its breeder; in a 2021 study it fell in the drought-sensitive group with 101-14, 420A and 5C
- 41B (Chasselas x V. berlandieri) remains essential in Cognac and is found in roughly 80% of Champagne's vineyards; it is sensitive to phylloxera but viable because the pest is not generally found in extremely chalky sites
Chalk, Chlorosis and the Search for Vitis berlandieri
As early as 1873, the agronomists Georges Couderc and Emile Planchon began creating rootstocks by hybridizing American vines resistant to the pest, but the first rootstocks were not suited to chalky soil. Not all American vines were immune to phylloxera, nor were all of them suited to France's growing conditions. Vitis riparia was the first rootstock judged both effective and commercially viable, but it performed well only in fertile, moist soils, and vinifera scions on riparia and on Vitis rupestris failed completely on chalk or limestone-rich soils. The cause was chlorosis, brought on by very basic (high pH) soils: France's famous white soils hold an abundance of active lime (CaCO3), which impedes the vine's uptake of iron. In 1887 the French Ministry of Agriculture sent Pierre Viala to the United States for six months to source vigorous American vines that resist phylloxera and grow in chalky soil. The answer was Vitis berlandieri, found in the limestone cliffs of Texas, which withstands phylloxera and suits French limestone soil. The rapid adoption of grafting led to a chaotic period from 1880 to 1930, when nurseries offered a confusing assortment of rootstocks and inappropriate choices caused lime-induced chlorosis.
- Vitis riparia: low vigor, damp tolerant, shallow rooting, early ripening
- Vitis rupestris: deep rooting
- Vitis berlandieri: deep rooting and essential for lime tolerance
The Key Rootstocks: Parentage, Origins and Vigor
SO4 (Oppenheim #4, also Selektion Oppenheim 4) is a berlandieri x riparia cross, recorded as Rességuier x V. riparia, from Germany; the School of Viticulture at Oppenheim released it in 1941, selected from Teleki 4A. 110R (Richter 110) crosses Rességuier no. 2 berlandieri with Rupestris Martin and was bred by Richter in France and released in 1889. 3309C (Couderc 3309) crosses Riparia tomenteuse with Rupestris Martin and was bred by Couderc in France and released in 1881. 101-14 Mgt (Millardet et de Grasset 101-14) is V. riparia x V. rupestris, bred by Millardet in France and released in 1882. Riparia Gloire de Montpellier is a pure V. riparia selection from France, with Viala listed as its breeder. Paulsen 1103 (1103P) crosses Rességuier no. 2 berlandieri with Rupestris du Lot and was released in Italy in 1895, and Kober 5BB, V. berlandieri x V. riparia, was released in Austria in 1930. On vigor, SO4, 3309C and 101-14 Mgt are moderate- to low-vigor rootstocks and might be reasonable choices for Malbec, a variety prone to coulure, while high-vigor rootstocks such as St. George, Freedom and 1103P should not be used with it.
- SO4: berlandieri x riparia; Germany, 1941; moderate to low vigor
- 110R: berlandieri x rupestris; Richter, 1889
- 3309C and 101-14 Mgt: both riparia x rupestris (Couderc, 1881; Millardet, 1882); moderate to low vigor
- Riparia Gloire de Montpellier: pure V. riparia; breeder Viala
- 41B: Chasselas x V. berlandieri; UC Davis Foundation Plant Services lists Millardet as breeder and 1882 as year released, while GuildSomm dates the cross to 1894
How Rootstock Shapes Vine Physiology and Wine Composition
The choice of a rootstock for a particular location depends on complex interactions among soil type and depth, soil physical and chemical properties, pests, diseases, water availability and environmental factors. Selection should be based on the type of soil pests present, the potential vigor of the site, vine spacing and desired vine size. How rootstocks affect the way a vine uses water is not completely understood. Dr. Gregory Gambetta of the University of Bordeaux believes drought resistance has something to do with the size of the root system, and says that “90% of the time, it’s the invigorating rootstocks that tend to be more adaptable to dry conditions,” while admitting his uncertainty. Potassium matters too: a surplus of potassium will decrease the acidity of the final wine, and Napa-based viticulturist Kelly Maher likes to use 110R on volcanic sites because it is a poor assimilator of potassium. Gambetta also believes that rootstocks almost certainly shift the growing season forward or backward by some measurable amount, but that much of the anecdotal evidence overstates the case. In his words, “The way vine species behave as rootstocks is not predictable; it is an interaction between the rootstock and the scion.”
- Rootstock selection rests on soil pests, the potential vigor of the site, vine spacing and desired vine size
- A surplus of potassium decreases the acidity of the finished wine
- Napa growers differ on ripening: Caleb Mosley favours 3309 because “the canopy hangs in there a little longer, through that last heatwave, to get those tannins over the line”
Regional Rootstock Choices and Their Terroir Logic
On chalk, the lime-tolerant 41B, a cross of V. berlandieri with Chasselas, remains essential in Cognac and can be found in roughly 80% of Champagne's vineyards. Having vinifera in the parentage generally makes a rootstock vulnerable to phylloxera, and 41B is sensitive to the pest, but it stays commercially viable because phylloxera is not generally found in extremely chalky sites. In the south of France, 110R and 140 Ruggeri are the majority rootstocks, and among the berlandieri hybrids authorised in France, SO4 and 110R are used in much of today's vineyards. California learned the vinifera lesson with AxR1, a cross between Aramon (V. vinifera) and V. rupestris: in 1983 a Napa grower noticed declining vines, university viticulturists found phylloxera feeding on the AxR1 rootstock, and a new biotype, named type B, had evolved to exploit it. Some vineyards still go without rootstocks: Malvasia de Colares and Ramisco grow ungrafted in the beach sand of Colares in Portugal, and on Santorini, whose volcanic soils are utterly lacking in clay, all vines are ungrafted.
- Cognac and Champagne: 41B, lime tolerant, essential in Cognac and found in roughly 80% of Champagne's vineyards
- South of France: 110R and 140 Ruggeri are the majority rootstocks
- California: AxR1 (Aramon x V. rupestris) failed when a new phylloxera biotype, type B, evolved to exploit it
- Ungrafted exceptions persist in the beach sand of Colares and the clay-free volcanic soils of Santorini
Climate Change and the Future of Rootstock Selection
Rupestris x berlandieri hybrids are given as the most drought-resistant rootstocks, and their use in the vineyard reflects it. In a 2021 study of rootstocks grafted onto Chardonnay, 110R, 1103P, 140 Ruggeri and Ramsey made up the drought-tolerant group, and 101-14, 420A, 5C and Riparia Gloire the drought-sensitive group. Published drought ratings for SO4 and 3309C differ from one author to another. At Château du Tertre in Margaux, where the sand and gravel soils are not calcareous, technical director Frédéric Ardouin says, “We mainly use 101-14 because it is a little more vigorous than Riparia Gloire,” and the estate has made recent plantings of Gravesac (V. riparia x V. rupestris x V. berlandieri) and 161-49 “because climate change imposes long dry periods.” The wider worry is genetic. Around 99% of commercially available rootstocks are made of some combination of riparia, rupestris and berlandieri, and when Dr. Walker's team examined the parentage of 60 rootstocks, most derived from the same selections: Rupestris St. George, Riparia Gloire and Berlandieri Resseguier S2. In his words, “This means there’s zero genetic diversity, which makes them highly vulnerable to evolutionary events like phylloxera collapse and nematodes.”
- Drought-tolerant in a 2021 study: 110R, 1103P, 140 Ruggeri and Ramsey; drought-sensitive: 101-14, 420A, 5C and Riparia Gloire
- Gravesac is a three-species cross: V. riparia x V. rupestris x V. berlandieri
- Around 99% of commercially available rootstocks combine riparia, rupestris and berlandieri, and most trace back to the same few selections
Sources and last verified
Primary sources: https://agate.inrae.fr/agate/en/content/1887a-viticultural-mission-america-save-french-vineyards, https://www.inrae.fr/en/news/phylloxera-genomics-sheds-light-history-invasion-french-vines-and-unveils-new-family-genes, https://fps.ucdavis.edu/fgrdetails.cfm?varietyid=1288, https://fps.ucdavis.edu/fgrdetails.cfm?varietyid=501, https://fps.ucdavis.edu/fgrdetails.cfm?varietyid=1280, https://fps.ucdavis.edu/fgrdetails.cfm?varietyid=1116, https://fps.ucdavis.edu/fgrdetails.cfm?varietyid=969, https://fps.ucdavis.edu/fgrdetails.cfm?varietyid=972, https://fps.ucdavis.edu/fgrdetails.cfm?varietyid=863, https://fps.ucdavis.edu/fgrdetails.cfm?varietyid=1147, https://extension.oregonstate.edu/sites/extd8/files/documents/ec1463.pdf, https://www.awri.com.au/industry_support/viticulture/pests-and-diseases/phylloxera/, https://cail.ucdavis.edu/publications/WeAreBothHosts.pdf, https://www.ucdavis.edu/blog/researchers-pinpoint-drought-resistant-traits-grape-rootstocks, https://devo.ucdavis.edu/sites/g/files/dgvnsk1961/files/media/documents/malbec.pdf, https://www.vignevin.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/1312_ESOPE_Acte_de_Colloque_BasseDef_A.pdf, https://mbartlett.faculty.ucdavis.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/583/2021/11/Bartlett_AOB_2021.pdf. Secondary sources: https://www.wsetglobal.com/knowledge-centre/blog/2023/february/09/what-is-phylloxera-and-why-was-it-so-significant, https://www.decanter.com/learn/grafting-46360/, https://www.guildsomm.com/public_content/features/articles/b/kelli-white/posts/grapevine-rootstocks, https://www.guildsomm.com/public_content/features/articles/b/jens-peter-nebsbjerg/posts/colares-wines-by-the-waves, https://www.guildsomm.com/public_content/features/articles/b/stamp/posts/volcano-island. Last verified 2026-11-02
The map that explains this region.
The World Atlas of Wine, now in its 9th edition, is the book I open before any trip and after any bottle I could not place. Every region on this page has a map in it.$70.
See the AtlasGrafting onto American rootstock keeps the desirable flavours of the vinifera grape variety. How a rootstock behaves is an interaction between the rootstock and the scion.
- Phylloxera (Daktulosphaira vitifoliae) is an aphid-like insect native to North America; it reached France in the 1860s on imported American vines, and by the late nineteenth century an estimated two-thirds of Europe's vineyards had been destroyed. Vitis vinifera has no defences, so it is grafted onto resistant American rootstock.
- Species traits: V. riparia is low vigor, damp tolerant, shallow rooting and early ripening; V. rupestris and V. berlandieri are deep rooting; V. berlandieri is essential for lime tolerance. Pierre Viala's 1887 mission to the United States sought vines that resist phylloxera and grow in chalky soil.
- Parentage and release: SO4 = berlandieri x riparia, Oppenheim, 1941; 110R = berlandieri x rupestris, Richter, 1889; 3309C = riparia x rupestris, Couderc, 1881; 101-14 Mgt = riparia x rupestris, Millardet, 1882; Riparia Gloire = pure riparia, Viala; 1103P = berlandieri x rupestris, Paulsen, 1895.
- 41B (Chasselas x V. berlandieri) is lime tolerant, essential in Cognac and found in roughly 80% of Champagne's vineyards, but sensitive to phylloxera; vinifera in a rootstock's parentage generally means vulnerability, as AxR1 (Aramon x V. rupestris) showed in California.
- Drought: in a 2021 study 110R, 1103P, 140 Ruggeri and Ramsey were drought tolerant, and 101-14, 420A, 5C and Riparia Gloire drought sensitive. Around 99% of commercially available rootstocks combine riparia, rupestris and berlandieri.