Viticulture Decisions as Terroir Expression: Yield, Farming Method, and Harvest Date

Growers decide how much fruit each vine carries, how the vineyard is farmed and when the grapes are picked. Thinning fruit raises sugar in the fruit that remains, and restricting yields, when done early enough or when green fruit is selected at veraison, shifts wine style rather than guaranteeing quality. Organic and biodynamic agriculture both reject synthetic inputs, and scientific research into the effects of biodynamics is sparse. The definition of ripeness depends on the style of wine intended, and the ideal potential alcohol does not always line up with flavour ripeness or phenolic ripeness.

Start WineSchool Level 1. Free, in the app, under a minute a lesson.

Open WineSchool

What It Means: Three Decisions in the Vineyard

Growers decide how much fruit each vine carries, how the vineyard is farmed and when the grapes are picked. The evidence behind each decision is different: lowering yields changes wine style when done early enough or when green fruit is selected at veraison, research into the effects of biodynamics is sparse, and the definition of ripeness depends on the style of wine intended.

  • Yield: with less fruit on the vine, the rate of sugar accumulation increases in the fruit that remains
  • Farming method: organic and biodynamic agriculture both reject synthetic inputs; biodynamics adds the special preparations 500 to 508
  • Harvest date: the definition of maturity used depends on the wine style intended
Key Facts
  • Burgundy's base yields are 35-37 hl/ha for Grand Cru reds and 40-64 hl/ha for Grand Cru whites, against 50-69 hl/ha for regional reds and 55-75 hl/ha for regional whites; subject to certain conditions and with permission, the base yield may be raised in a given year by 15 to 20 percent
  • With less fruit on the vine, sugar accumulates faster in the fruit that remains; cutting the fruit in half or more might raise sugar by as much as 10 to 20 percent
  • Restricting yields, when done early enough or when green fruit is selected at veraison, shifts wine style, and there are no set crop levels that will guarantee the best fruit quality
  • Organic and biodynamic agriculture both reject synthetic inputs, organic certification is the minimum requirement for biodynamic certification, and biodynamics adds special preparations numbered 500 to 508
  • Scientific research into the effects of biodynamics is sparse; many studies compare only organic with conventional viticulture, or group organic and biodynamic vineyards together
  • The ideal potential alcohol for a wine does not always correspond to flavour ripeness or phenolic ripeness
  • Red varieties grown in hot climates might need a relatively early harvest, because sugar can reach an optimum before other grape constituents are at desirable levels

How Yield Management Shapes Wine Style

In Burgundy, the maximum base yield for each appellation is defined by legislation in hl/ha: 35-37 hl/ha for Grand Cru reds and 40-64 hl/ha for Grand Cru whites, against 50-69 hl/ha for regional reds and 55-75 hl/ha for regional whites. Subject to certain conditions, the base yield may be raised in a given year by 15 to 20 percent, and the grower has to obtain permission. Growers lower yields by thinning fruit, also called green harvesting, or by limiting bud numbers at pruning. With less fruit on the vine, sugar accumulates faster in the fruit that remains, and the earlier in the season thinning is done, the more sugar ends up in the remaining fruit. The effect has a ceiling: cutting the fruit in half or more might raise sugar by as much as 10 to 20 percent, which could lift a potential alcohol of 11% to 13%. Oregon State University notes that research worldwide shows conflicting evidence on lighter yields and higher fruit quality, suggesting that yield management depends on the balance of a given vineyard.

  • Crop thinning can be done at any time from pre-bloom through just prior to harvest; most Oregon growers cluster-thin between fruit set and bunch close or during lag phase
  • Vineyard consultant Steve Matthiasson, writing for GuildSomm, calls restricting yields a change in style, but not necessarily quality, and his view is that an effect on wine flavour needs fruit thinning very early, well before veraison, while Oregon State University says very early crop thinning has not been found to be necessary for Pinot noir in most western Oregon vineyards
  • Thinning at or near fruit set has been shown to increase phenolics (mouthfeel characters) and anthocyanins (color) in the berry by harvest
  • There is a point of diminishing returns with fruit thinning, and fruity, high-acid wines such as rosés are much better at higher crop loads
  • White grapes react very differently from red grapes to fruit thinning: a heavier crop slows ripening
  • In cold, marginal sites, without a severely low crop the fruit may not be able to get ripe; in hot growing areas, enough fruit on the vine tempers sugar production

Farming Method: Organic and Biodynamic, Described

Organic and biodynamic agriculture both reject synthetic inputs, and organic certification is the minimum requirement for biodynamic certification. Biodynamics derives from eight lectures Rudolf Steiner gave in 1924 at the request of a group of farmers in Koberwitz, in present-day Poland, and treats the farm as a self-sustaining, closed organism. Its main practical difference from organic farming is the special preparations 500 to 508, made from cow manure, quartz (silica) and seven medicinal plants, either sprayed on the vines in homeopathic quantities or added to the soil via compost. Practitioners describe preparation 500, horn manure, as stimulating soil life and root growth; one of the most common criticisms is that such tiny quantities, a single horn per hectare, cannot have the suggested beneficial effects. Both Biodyvin and Demeter have rules on growing and vinification that can be stricter than organic alone.

  • Scientific research into the effects of biodynamics is sparse: many studies look only at organic versus conventional viticulture, or group organic and biodynamic vineyards together
  • A 2019 systematic review by Döring et al. of 24 studies found increased biodiversity in organic and biodynamic viticulture compared to conventional, and lower reported yields and lower-vigor vines in the organic systems, with no suggestion of a likely difference between organic and biodynamic
  • Single studies differ: in a Rheingau study (Hendgen et al. 2018) the biodynamic preparations affected neither fungal composition nor richness compared with organic, while a 2020 study of five organic vineyards in Burgundy (Fritz et al.) observed strong effects from the preparations that varied from site to site
  • Another explanation offered for any perceived benefits of biodynamics is that the grower is spending more time and attention on the land

Harvest Date: Choosing the Ripeness You Want

Ripeness can be defined in several ways, including juice or pulp maturity, skin maturity, phenolic maturity, aromatic maturity and seed maturity, and the definition used depends on the wine style intended. Winemakers often use potential alcohol as a guide to when the grapes should be picked, but the ideal potential alcohol for a particular wine does not always correspond to flavour ripeness (when the grapes taste great) or phenolic ripeness. Phenolic ripeness shows in the glass: if noticeably bitter flavours dominate the palate, the wine is not considered phenolically ripe; if the tannins of a red wine are supple and rounded, the grapes were phenolically ripe when picked.

  • Some dry white styles need grapes whose aromatic substances are at maximal concentration and whose acidity is relatively high, which might in some cases require an early harvest
  • Red varieties grown in hot climates might need a relatively early harvest, because sugar can reach an optimum before other grape constituents are at desirable levels
  • Full lignification of the seed (cracking upon crushing) is desirable for red wine styles but often lags behind other measures of ripeness
  • Weather can cut the wait short: in California in 2010 or 2011, early rains cut short the prospect of long hang time

The Science: Leaf Area, Fruit and Vine Balance

If other factors are equal, the ratio of leaves to fruit greatly determines the rate and amount of sugar loading in the berries. Bunch thinning works by raising that leaf area to fruit ratio, which is optimal between 6 and 15 cm2 per gram of fruit and can lead to better sugar accumulation and ripening speed. Crop thinning is an important way to increase winegrape quality and balance vine growth when vegetative growth is lacking and crop loads are high relative to the vine size, but how it is done, if at all, depends on site, cultivar and production methods.

  • All else being equal, the main thing is the ratio of leaf area to fruit load over time
  • Fruit thinning as a standard quality practice was, in 2013, a fairly recent phenomenon, developed over the previous thirty years or so, and it originally evolved in high-end estates in cooler growing regions
  • Among European biodynamic and natural wine producers there is a move away from fruit thinning; some biodynamic producers believe it interrupts the vine's natural ripening rhythm, and where lower yields are needed they leave fewer buds at pruning

Where You Will Find It: Producers in Their Own Words

Two estates describe their farming on their own sites. Domaine Leflaive's own timeline dates its move to biodynamics to 1992-1996, and the domaine says it has cultivated its vines biodynamically for more than 25 years. Felton Road, at Bannockburn in Central Otago, states that its vineyards have been managed organically and biodynamically since 2002 and that pruning leaves desired bud numbers to ensure moderate, controllable yields.

  • Burgundy: Domaine Leflaive, Puligny-Montrachet; biodynamics from 1992-1996
  • Central Otago: Felton Road, Bannockburn; organic and biodynamic since 2002

Sources and last verified

Primary sources: https://www.bourgogne-wines.com/glossary/yield,2532,9412.html, https://extension.oregonstate.edu/sites/extd8/files/documents/lommena/em9071.pdf. Producers' own sites: https://www.leflaive.fr/en_US/the-hand-of-man, https://www.leflaive.fr/en_US/a-emotion-for-4-generations, https://feltonroad.com/our-land-vines/. Secondary sources: https://www.guildsomm.com/public_content/features/articles/b/a_year_in_the_vineyard/posts/yields, https://www.guildsomm.com/research/mw-perspectives/b/mw-perspectives/posts/the-relevance-of-biodynamics, https://www.guildsomm.com/public_content/features/articles/b/guest_blog/posts/organic-biodynamic-and-natural-wines-explained, https://www.decanter.com/learn/biodynamic-wines-explained-472503/, https://www.decanter.com/learn/wine-terminology/phenolic-ripeness-ask-decanter-296358/, https://www.awri.com.au/wp-content/uploads/6_phenology_defining_berry_ripeness.pdf, https://www.awri.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/on-farm-trials-manual-2-6.pdf. Last verified 2026-11-02

From the WineShopAffiliate

The map that explains this region.

The World Atlas of Wine, now in its 9th edition, is the book I open before any trip and after any bottle I could not place. Every region on this page has a map in it.$70.

See the Atlas
Exam Study NotesWSET / CMS
  • Burgundy base yields: Grand Cru reds 35-37 hl/ha, Grand Cru whites 40-64 hl/ha; regional reds 50-69 hl/ha, regional whites 55-75 hl/ha. Subject to conditions and with permission, the base yield may be raised in a given year by 15 to 20 percent.
  • Thinning fruit raises sugar in the remaining fruit, but cutting the fruit in half or more might add as much as 10 to 20 percent sugar. Restricting yields, when done early enough or when green fruit is selected at veraison, changes wine style, not necessarily quality, and there are no set crop levels that will guarantee the best fruit quality.
  • Organic and biodynamic both reject synthetic inputs; organic certification is the minimum for biodynamic certification. Biodynamics derives from Steiner's eight lectures of 1924 and uses preparations 500 to 508. Scientific research into its effects is sparse.
  • Ripeness types: juice or pulp, skin, phenolic, aromatic and seed maturity. The ideal potential alcohol does not always correspond to flavour or phenolic ripeness; red varieties in hot climates might need a relatively early harvest.