Natural and Low-Intervention Winemaking
What the words natural and low intervention usually cover, which bodies have written their own rules, and where no definition exists at all.
Natural wine is best thought of, in WSET's words, as an ethos rather than a style of wine, and the term is rarely written on a label. Decanter reported in 2020 that natural wines had so far defied all attempts to create a legal definition, and in the United States the federal ruling on the word 'natural' says its policies do not define the term. 'Low intervention' is widely used to describe natural wine, yet no legal or formal definition of it was found in EU or US rules or in the trade sources reviewed for this article. Rules written by particular bodies include the French Vin Méthode Nature designation, devised by a union of natural wine producers, and the entry criteria of tastings and fairs. Practices commonly associated with the terms, as these accounts describe them, include organic or biodynamic farming, fermentation by the yeasts of the vineyard and winery, little or no added sulfur dioxide, no additives, and little or no fining and filtration.
Start WineSchool Level 1. Free, in the app, under a minute a lesson.
Open WineSchoolWhat the Terms Mean
WSET suggests thinking of natural wine as an ethos rather than a style of wine, and notes that the term 'natural wine' is rarely written on a label. It adds that it is widely agreed that the aim of natural wine is to get the grape from vineyard to bottle with as little added or removed as possible. 'Low intervention' is widely used to describe natural wine. To some, WSET says, this could suggest that little work is done, when the reality can be quite the opposite: by choosing not to use additions or adjustments, natural winemakers must be careful in the vineyard to ensure healthy, ripe and disease-free grapes, and they have fewer options if a fault begins to creep into the wine. No legal or formal definition of 'low intervention' was found in EU or US rules or in the trade sources reviewed for this article. Some people draw a line between the two terms. Isabelle Legeron MW, founder of the RAW wine fair, told Decanter in 2020: 'We make the distinction between "natural wines" and "low-intervention organic and biodynamic wines"', and said the fair accepts both but refers to them as two distinct categories. Organic wine, by contrast, has been legally defined in both the vineyard and the cellar, though certification rules may vary. In Legeron's words, 'all natural wines are organic but not all organic wines are natural', and practices begin to diverge in the cellar.
- Natural wine: an ethos rather than a style, in WSET's framing, and rarely named on a label
- Low intervention: widely used to describe natural wine; no legal or formal definition found
- Organic wine: legally defined in vineyard and cellar, with certification rules that may vary
- Legeron: broadly speaking, organic cellar rules permit additives like yeast, aids like fining agents and processing like sterile filtration and pasteurisation that would not be allowed at all in natural winemaking
- Decanter reported in 2020 that natural wines had so far defied all attempts to create a legal definition; WSET notes that the makers of these wines are often not legally bound by a specific set of rules
- United States: under 27 CFR 4.21 any grape wine containing no added grape brandy or alcohol may be further designated 'natural', and ATF Ruling 85-4 says its policies do not define the term 'natural' but indicate when ATF takes no exception to its use
- 'Low intervention' is widely used to describe natural wine, but no legal or formal definition of the term was found; Isabelle Legeron MW distinguishes 'natural wines' from 'low-intervention organic and biodynamic wines'
- Vin Méthode Nature, as Jancis Robinson reported in 2020, is a French designation devised by a union of natural wine producers: hand-picked grapes certified organic, yeast from the vineyard and/or winery, no additions such as acid, sugar, tannin, water or colouring matter, and sulfites either not added or added modestly just before bottling, to a final level not over 30 mg/L
- Decanter wrote in 2024 that it is generally agreed natural wine should be farmed organically or biodynamically, made with minimal intervention and without additives, and that most also feel it should be unfined and unfiltered; sulfite addition is the only substantial area of disagreement
- Natural-wine sulfite figures are each body's own rule, not law: 30 mg/L for Vin Méthode Nature, 70 mg/L for Decanter's 2017 tasting and for wines shown at RAW fairs; in the EU, Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/934 sets total SO2 maxima, for wines other than sparkling and liqueur wines, of 150 mg/L for red and 200 mg/L for white and rosé wines below 5 g/L sugar
- Mousy taint, an off-flavour reminiscent of caged mice or sometimes cracker biscuit, is usually of microbial origin, has no satisfactory method of removal, and is more likely in wines with low SO2 and low acidity
Natural Wine and the Law
No legal definition of natural wine was found in the wine rules of the European Union or the United States. Decanter reported in 2020 that natural wines had so far defied all attempts to create a legal definition, and Jancis Robinson wrote in 2010 that 'There is no official definition of natural wine', adding that its adherents would rather revel and party than define and organise. When Decanter set up a natural wine tasting in 2017, it wrote that, as there is no strict definition of natural wine, deciding the entry criteria was not easy, so it sought advice from industry figures and came up with its own charter. In the United States the word 'natural' does appear in federal wine labeling rules, with a narrow meaning. Under 27 CFR 4.21, any grape wine containing no added grape brandy or alcohol may be further designated 'natural'. ATF Ruling 85-4, published on the TTB website, says 27 CFR 4.21 permits the term in reference to grape wine, citrus wine, fruit wine and wine from other agricultural products which contain no added alcohol or brandy, that no other type of wine may be designated 'natural', and that these policies do not define the term 'natural' but indicate when ATF takes no exception to its use. This article does not cover the wine laws of other countries.
- EU and US: no legal definition of natural wine found; Decanter (2020) says natural wines have defied all attempts to create one
- US labels (27 CFR 4.21): 'natural' may further designate a grape wine containing no added grape brandy or alcohol
- ATF Ruling 85-4: no other type of wine may be designated 'natural', and the policies do not define the term
- Written rules found belong to particular bodies, with no statement here on official recognition: a producers' union's designation, a magazine's tasting criteria and a fair's sulfite cap
Vin Méthode Nature
In France, a group of natural wine producers has written its own rules. Jancis Robinson reported in April 2020 that the designation Vin Méthode Nature is the work of a union of natural wine producers led by two in the Loire, Jacques Carroget of La Paonnerie in Muscadet country and Sébastien David, a St-Nicolas-de-Bourgueil vigneron. The same article names the Syndicat de Défense des Vins Naturels and refers to it as 'the French union'. In her account, a Vin Méthode Nature must be made from hand-picked grapes certified as organically grown by one of the major certifying organisations, the yeast for fermentation must be that found in the vineyard and/or winery, not bought in, and all additions such as acid, sugar, tannin, water and colouring matter are forbidden. The wine must not have been treated with interventionist physical procedures; Robinson names heating red wine grape must for deeper colour and a sudden blast of heat to stabilise wine among the practices excluded. Sulfites are either not added at all, or added only, and modestly, just before bottling so that the wine's final level does not exceed 30 mg/L. There are two versions of the logo, one for no added sulfites and one for wines whose sulfite level is guaranteed to be less than 30 mg/L. Robinson set this against the 70 mg/L maximum that Isabelle Legeron MW sets for wines shown at her RAW wine fairs, calling 30 mg/L 'pretty strict'. She also asked how the designation would be policed, expecting producers to fill in a forest of forms backed up by the odd random inspection, and quoted the natural wine author Alice Feiring: 'In my heart of hearts, I just don't think natural wine is certifiable.'
- Grapes: hand-picked and certified organic by one of the major certifying organisations
- Yeast: that found in the vineyard and/or winery, not bought in
- Additions such as acid, sugar, tannin, water and colouring matter: forbidden
- Sulfites: none added, or added modestly just before bottling to a final level not over 30 mg/L, with two logos to mark the difference
Practices Associated with Natural Wine
Decanter wrote in 2024 that it is generally agreed that natural wine should be farmed organically or biodynamically, made with minimal intervention, meaning no techniques such as flash pasteurisation, and without additives, and that most also feel it should be unfined and unfiltered. WSET adds that many natural winemakers adhere to organic or biodynamic practices as a minimum standard. Ambient yeasts that exist in the vineyard and winery spontaneously ferment natural wine, as opposed to the commercial yeasts commonly used for conventional production. Very little to no sulfur dioxide is added, and natural wines have often undergone minimal clarification and filtration, stages that natural winemakers consider interventions that would strip out the wine's particular aromas and reduce its complexity. WSET notes that working this way can make the wine less stable. Producers may also use less machinery, harvest by hand and use natural vessels such as clay to ferment or store their wine. In a spontaneous, or uninoculated, fermentation, the species present on the surface of the grape appear to dominate at first; as fermentation progresses their levels decrease while that of Saccharomyces increases, and by the end Saccharomyces is the majority of the yeast found. Angiolino Maule of La Biancara near Gambellara, in Veneto, founded VinNatur in 2006; Decanter reported in 2024 that the non-profit association has more than 300 winemaker members in 12 countries and funds research, including a study of mouse taint.
- Decanter's 2017 tasting criteria: vineyards farmed organically or biodynamically (certification strongly preferred), hand-harvested only, fermentation with indigenous (wild) yeasts, no enzymes
- Same criteria: no additives (such as acid, tannin or colouring) other than SO2, and SO2 no higher than 70 mg/L total
- Same criteria: unfined, with no or light filtration, and no other heavy manipulation such as spinning cone, reverse osmosis, cryoextraction, rapid-finishing or ultraviolet C irradiation
- Orange wine: not exclusively natural, but often made with natural winemaking techniques, in WSET's account
Sulfites, Stability and Faults
Decanter calls the addition of sulfites the only substantial area of disagreement among natural wine advocates: some say none should be added, some say only up to 30 ppm, others say less than 70 ppm. Those are positions among natural wine advocates; the EU and US figures found for this article follow. In the European Union, Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/934 provides that the total sulphur dioxide content of wines other than sparkling and liqueur wines, on release for direct human consumption, may not exceed 150 mg/L for red wines and 200 mg/L for white and rosé wines, raised to 200 and 250 mg/L where the sugar content, expressed as the sum of glucose and fructose, is not less than 5 g/L. For EU organic wine, Implementing Regulation (EU) 2021/1165 sets 100 mg/L for red wines and 150 mg/L for white and rosé wines with residual sugar below 2 g/L, and reduces the maximum for all other wines by 30 mg/L. In the United States, 27 CFR 4.22(b)(1) provides that the presence in finished wine of not more than 350 parts per million of total sulfur dioxide shall not be precluded, and 27 CFR 4.32(e) requires 'Contains sulfites' or an equivalent statement where sulfur dioxide is detected at 10 or more parts per million. Some 10 to 50 mg/L of sulfur dioxide is produced naturally during fermentation, so no wine is truly sulfur dioxide free. Making wine without added SO2 is, in Decanter's words, 'fraught with challenges', and it says no-sulphites-added wines are more liable to wine faults, bottle variation and premature ageing. Robinson notes that, because they have not been subjected to conventional stabilisation such as filtration or fining, finished natural wines may re-ferment if they get too warm when stored or transported. Mousy taint is one fault tied to low SO2. It is an off-flavour reminiscent of caged mice or sometimes cracker biscuit, generally perceived late on the palate or after the wine has been swallowed or spat out, and rarely detected by sniffing because the compounds involved are not volatile at wine pH. It is usually of microbial origin, with most strains of lactic acid bacteria capable of producing it, and the yeast Dekkera/Brettanomyces may also be capable of producing mousy compounds. There is no satisfactory method to remove it, and it is more likely in wines with low SO2 and low acidity. The AWRI observed an increased incidence of mousy wines in the 1990s, when winemakers moved to a lower sulfur dioxide regime for red wines in particular, and again in the 2010s, when some experimented with extended lees ageing, high pH with minimal SO2, oxidative ageing and minimal clarification or filtration in white wines. Increased acetic acid in stored wines is usually attributable to acetic acid bacteria, which convert alcohol to acetic acid in the presence of oxygen. On the wines themselves, WSET says it is common to experience variation in the same labelled wine year to year, or occasionally even bottle to bottle, and that some unexpected aromas may be challenging to a newcomer. Robinson wrote in 2010 that she loved the theory but found natural wines 'frustratingly unpredictable', with some 'all too reminiscent of cider that's gone off', while successful ones have a vitality and personality that set them apart from the commercial mainstream. Critics of the label itself, Decanter reports, say it is unhelpful to infer that other wines are somehow inferior or do not properly reflect their origins.
- Advocates' sulfite positions (Decanter, 2024): none added, up to 30 ppm, or under 70 ppm
- EU (Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/934): 150 mg/L red, 200 mg/L white and rosé, raised to 200 and 250 mg/L at 5 g/L sugar or more; EU organic (Implementing Regulation (EU) 2021/1165): 100 and 150 mg/L below 2 g/L residual sugar
- US (27 CFR 4.22(b)(1) and 4.32(e)): not more than 350 ppm total SO2 not precluded; 'Contains sulfites' at 10 ppm or more
- Mousy taint: usually from lactic acid bacteria, possibly Dekkera/Brettanomyces; no satisfactory method to remove it; more likely at low SO2 and low acidity
- Fermentation itself produces some 10 to 50 mg/L of SO2, so no wine is truly sulfur dioxide free
Sources and last verified
Primary sources (ATF Ruling 85-4 via the TTB; 27 CFR part 4, 4.22 and 4.32 via eCFR; Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/934 and Implementing Regulation (EU) 2021/1165 via EUR-Lex): https://www.ttb.gov/laws-regulations-and-public-guidance/rulings/85-4 https://www.ecfr.gov/api/versioner/v1/full/2026-11-12/title-27.xml?part=4 https://www.ecfr.gov/api/renderer/v1/content/enhanced/current/title-27?section=4.22 https://www.ecfr.gov/api/renderer/v1/content/enhanced/current/title-27?section=4.32 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:02019R0934-20241229 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:02021R1165-20260101 Secondary sources (WSET Global; Decanter; Jancis Robinson; Australian Wine Research Institute; UC Davis): https://www.wsetglobal.com/knowledge-centre/blog/2023/january/13/what-is-natural-wine https://www.decanter.com/learn/organic-and-natural-wine-difference-433116/ https://www.decanter.com/learn/advice/what-is-natural-wine-ask-decanter-368773/ https://www.decanter.com/premium/natural-wine-a-lens-on-the-future-of-wine-and-winemaking-543179/ https://www.decanter.com/learn/no-sulphites-added-wine-the-great-debate-451195/ https://www.jancisrobinson.com/articles/natural-wine-defined https://www.jancisrobinson.com/articles/naked-as-nature-intended https://www.awri.com.au/industry_support/winemaking_resources/sensory_assessment/recognition-of-wine-faults-and-taints/wine_faults/ https://www.awri.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2011/07/Technical_Review_Issue_216_Stockley.pdf https://wineserver.ucdavis.edu/industry-info/enology/wine-microbiology/yeast-mold/diversity-wine-yeasts Last verified 2026-11-13
Open one bottle, taste it for weeks.
The Coravin Pivot+ is the simpler Coravin, for wines you will finish inside a few weeks, which is how I taste a producer across vintages without finishing every bottle. It takes five seconds to use.$199.
See the Pivot+- No legal definition of natural wine was found in EU or US rules; Decanter (2020): natural wines have so far defied all attempts to create a legal definition. WSET: an ethos rather than a style, rarely named on a label.
- US: 27 CFR 4.21 and ATF Ruling 85-4 let wine with no added grape brandy or alcohol be designated 'natural' (grape, citrus, fruit and other agricultural wines); no other type of wine may be, and the ruling does not define the term.
- Low intervention: widely used to describe natural wine (WSET), with no legal or formal definition found; Isabelle Legeron MW separates natural wines from low-intervention organic and biodynamic wines.
- Vin Méthode Nature (France, reported by Jancis Robinson in 2020): a producers' union's designation; hand-picked certified organic grapes, vineyard and/or winery yeast, no additions, sulfites none or a final level not over 30 mg/L; two logos.
- Natural-wine sulfite figures (30 mg/L Vin Méthode Nature; 70 mg/L Decanter's 2017 tasting and RAW fairs) are bodies' own rules. EU 2019/934 (wines other than sparkling and liqueur wines): 150 mg/L red and 200 mg/L white and rosé below 5 g/L sugar; US 27 CFR 4.22(b)(1): not more than 350 ppm total SO2 is not precluded. Mousy taint is more likely at low SO2 and low acidity.